The plot follows harry s second year at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, during which a series of messages on the walls of the schools corridors warn that the chamber of secrets has been opened and that the heir of slytherin would. By examining the listed attributes, one must agree that harry potter possesses and displays the characteristics of a classic greek hero. So dont feel bad if you find yourself trading in an older copy of a classic novel for a newer, sleeker edition. Do you think harry potter will ever be considered classic. Some equate the books with the fantasy novels written by c. What distinguishes harry potter from great literature. The hunger games definitely has the potential to be a future classic.
Its an incredibly organic and introspective series with themes that resonate with all ages, it touches on the issues that are relevant today and provides insight on them, it had an enormous effect on the psyche of our current generation, and radically altered the literature and media world for the better. The first book, harry potter and the philosophers stone won the attention of scottish newspapers, such as the glasgow herald, which said that the book was a magic stuff eccleshare, 10 and the scotsman newspaper, which announced that it had all the makings of a classic eccleshare, 10. You must agree that the world of jk rowlings harry potter is, in fact, full of meaning other than the greater focus on hp himself. It was published worldwide in english on 21 june 2003. The day harry potter becomes a classic is the day the rest of us might as well give up trying to write real fiction because there really is no hope at that point. Oct 11, 2015 harry potter is not the best written novel, but it will no doubt go down in history as a classic. Jun 23, 2000 the worst the future might say of harry potter is that it is a classic in the sense that p g wodehouse is a classic, rather than in the sense that henry james is. Rowlings birth name before she took a pen name and a. Rowling had lifted chunks of the potterverse from other sources. Treasure island ignited the chain of adventure novels right up to books as modern as harry potter. Thus, he attends hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry to practice magic under the guidance of the kindly headmaster albus dumbledore and other school professors along.
Both of harry s parents, lily and james potter, were wizards like harry. Jan 02, 2019 pensive and brooding with a penchant for solitary confinement, your fantastic story unfolded within the pages of bram stokers gothic classic, dracula. Why can harry potter not be considered great literature. There are multiple sacrifices made throughout all seven books. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone analysis shmoop. When it does, it will be considered on par with tolkiens works and narnia maybe not tolkiens, but you know what i mean. Like any magic worth an incantation, harry potter and the cursed child, opening on broadway at the lyric theater tonight, depends on unspoiled illusions, a delight in lifes wonders and the skills. The british magical community of the harry potter books is inspired by 1990s british culture, european folklore, classical mythology and. What was the first book in the harry potter series. Rowlings series of harry potter books shot up the bestseller lists, it also rose to top the list of most banned and challenged books between 2000 and 2009, according. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is a partial mystery novel with a series of secrets and inadvertent lies, which may be the most dangerous kind. Before harry potter, childrens literature was often considered an afterthought. Christian version of harry potter christian version of harry potter rumor.
The novel deals with the ability of science to create a new species of life. Harry potter is not destined to be a classic, but its not a just trend that will pass, believes lisa dennis. Who knows what could happen, will there even be literature classes. The series is most often referred to as fantasy, but with the first few novels reading like classic young detective stories and later ones covering everything from true crime the investigations into voldemorts past in hbp could be about a serial killer to heist scenes in dh, and even scenes reminiscent of gangster movies the dark lord rising, would it be fair to say that crime fiction has. Awards and prizes harry potter harry potter books and. The harry potter controversy has gone on, in one form or another, for years, particularly before the series ended. What you need to know about fantasy books and movies, he discusses why the j. Rowlings harry potter and the deathly hallows in 2007 the seventh and final novel about the british teenage boy wizard. Like 1984 or brave new world, collins dystopian novel features the best and worst aspects of society.
The harry potter novels have become the bestselling book series of all. In 500 years, will harry potter be taught as classic literature. With daniel radcliffe, rupert grint, richard harris, maggie smith. Rowlings creative character harry potter serves as a wonderful example of the classic mythological hero.
Harry potter and the philosophers stone 76,944 words. It respects kids intelligence and motivates them to tackle its greater length and complexity, play imaginative games, and try to solve its logic puzzles. Rowling published the cuckoos calling, her first postpotter book, she decided to go by the name robert. One recurring question concerns whether the harry potter books are. Reading harry potter as literature, is the first event in the world to look at the series as a. He is the standard classic hero, the best of the best, the cream of the crop. Let potter make the money, but let the classics be known forever on the merit of their literary greatness. Why harry potter is great literature humane pursuits.
Harry potter and the chamber of secrets is a classic novel, as the novels characters have been involved in a series of engaging complications. Aug 18, 2015 6 reasons why harry potter is the best story of a generation louise mcdowell august 18, 2015 i have been a harry potter fan ever since i was 7 years old when my mum brought home the first book. All these things are just some of the many factors that would need to be considered. Why would the hunger games be considered a classic in the. Its harry potters story that makes it good, not its use of the english language. Harry tries to keep his reaction to the dementors under wraps. I dont think that literary critics have come to any consensus as to a clear and concise definition of great literature but this is my generic criteria, which anyone may choose to accept or reject. The plot isnt the most complex, but its relatively easy to understand and its very fun. Harry potter made ya booktomovie franchises into one of the biggest. A school in nashville has removed harry potter books from its library, citing the spells used in the book as real.
Harry potter is a series of fantasy novels written by british author j. Another prominent sacrifice, one of the most upsetting deaths in the harry potter novels, is when dobby, the house elf is killed by bellatrix while saving potter, weasley, and granger. Sep 20, 2017 the idea of the doorway in this novel linking the real to the magical was used years later by j. On one side of the harry potter controversy are those who say that j. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets 85,141 words. And surrounding them are a smattering of books now considered classics published during my own lifetime. Parents need to know that harry potter and the sorcerers stone is a thrillaminute story, the first in j. In his book, harry potter, narnia, and the lord of the rings. Since the publication of the sorcerers stone in 1997, kids have discussed, dissected and debated the. The harry potter book series is considered one of the greatest series in. List of books and articles about harry potter online.
Harry potter author conjures pseudonym for debut crime novel. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone emerged from the creative mind of j. Harry is a representation of all the best qualities in our society. Potter and the philosophers stone has all the makings of a classic. Tom marvolo riddle 31 december 1926 2 may 1998, later known as lord voldemort or, alternatively as youknowwho, hewhomustnotbenamed, or the dark lord, was an english halfblood wizard considered to have been the most powerful and dangerous dark wizard of all time. Jk rowlings books about the hogwarts wizard have been the subject of. It is the first novel in the harry potter series and rowlings debut novel, first published in 1997 by bloomsbury. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets is a fantasy novel written by british author j. The above harry potter sets are just some examples of. Lets take a closer look at some of the arguments surrounding these seven books.
In the lord of the rings, sam gamgee speaks nostalgically about the great stories, the ones that really mattered. Jk rowlings harry potter and the sorcerers stone hit us bookshelves 15 years ago. Treasure island can definitely be considered the archetype of adventure novels, alongside tom sawyer and huckleberry finn. Joanna kathleen rowling on a train ride from manchester to london in 1990. The difference between a classic and harry potter is that while it can be considered classic literature, it is also a childrens book because it was written directly for children although adults enjoy it. Harry james potter is the titular protagonist of j. Jun 07, 2018 the harry potter series is an absolute classic, one that is near and dear to my heart, but it is also a book series with more than a few toxic male characters in it.
Well, harry potter, if assessed, would gain about an f for the way its written. Nov 18, 20 as a result, the most powerful themes of the harry potter books are about identityand they are profoundly countercultural. Does the harry potter series deserve to be called a classic. On what novel is the film slumdog millionaire based. Harry s mother protecting harry from voldemort is the sacrifice made from love that leads to harry s fate in the future. Feb 07, 2018 for the same reason that harry potter is not considered classic literature by most people. The main story arc concerns harry s struggle against lord voldemort, a dark wizard who intends to become immortal, overthrow the. Harry potter and the philosophers stone is a fantasy novel written by british author j. The first is how it sets the tone for the rest of the harry potter series. And in harry potter, a modern teenager can watch a boy struggle with the same things he does, and see precisely what ultimately distinguishes the boy from the man he becomesnamely, things that would terrify the benevolent technocrats and progressiveminded. Shes a specialist in childrens books for the carnegie library of pittsburgh and has read all six of the adventures. I recently had the opportunity to speak with richard about his book. The classic hero harry is a representation of all the best qualities in our society. The novels chronicle the lives of a young wizard, harry potter, and his friends hermione granger and ron weasley, all of whom are students at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry.
This question raises huge amounts of debate among christian experts. May 29, 2018 alan rickman expressed frustrations over harry potter. In harry potter and the order of the phoenix is it revealed that when sybill trelawney the divinations professor was being interviewed for. Top 10 most popular books of all time fact retriever. It reminds us that were clearly in the fantasy genre with the idea of sorcerers and lets us know right away who our hero is harry potter. Here are some other reasons they should totally, definitely be banned. Jk rowlings muchloved harry potter book series has won countless book awards. Call it a fan fiction of a weak to strong mc living in the harry potter world. Shes a specialist in childrens books for the carnegie library of pittsburgh and has read all six of the. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone sounds exciting and magical. Jun 07, 2005 by comparison, the last harry potter novel, 2003s harry potter and the order of the phoenix, was issued with 8. In my eyes, harry potter is a modern classic, while narnia is another kind of classic. There are three main points on why i believe harry potter and the chamber of secrets is a classic novel and part of the western canon. One recurring question concerns whether the harry potter books are quality literature, popular fad or a bit of both.
It has been translated into 47 languages and has been adapted for tv, stage, radio, and hollywood. If you can ignore the iteration of harry potter and those cringy moments, the story and lore are very well done. Thus, he attends hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry to practice magic under the guidance of the kindly headmaster albus dumbledore and other school professors. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban 107,253 words. You can say that that is a universal system of signs.
Harper lees new novel big as harry potter in amazon pre. Tolkien while others believe that the books promote the occult through witchcraft and spells. The difference between a classic and harry potter is that while it can be considered classic literature, it is also a childrens book because it was. Rowling and the second novel in the harry potter series. Should christians be reading the harry potter books. The chronicles of narnia were written sixty years ago. There is certainly no consensus on what even constitutes quality literature. The harry potter book series is considered one of the greatest series in literary history, beginning its commercial life on this day, twenty years ago j. Harry potter and the halfblood prince was published on 16 july 2005. The majority of the books plot covers seven years in the life of the orphan harry, who, on his eleventh birthday, learns he is a wizard. The books tell the story of an orphaned boy who discovers hes a wizard with magic powers. It was published in the united states as harry potter and the sorcerers stone by scholastic corporation in 1998.
Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban themes shmoop. He has many special traits and a great heroic past. She studied classics in university, so shes got a lot of greek mythology in there, too. Rowling was a single mother of an infant daughter and living on welfare in edinburgh, scotland, when she began the novel. Rowlings harry potter series is vastly different from the christianbased works of c.
Jul 14, 20 harry potter author conjures pseudonym for debut crime novel. Treasure island sparked the narrative arc, with an introduction, problem, solution and happy ending. Hermione doesnt tell even her bffs about her timeturner. Bernard ashleys the trouble with donovan croft 1974 is an oxford modern classic. An orphaned boy enrolls in a school of wizardry, where he learns the truth about himself, his family and the terrible evil that haunts the magical world. Do you think harry potter would be considered classic. Harry potter and the philosophers stone, the first in the harry potter series of novels, was published in 1997. Narnia has survived the test of time, hp hasnt yet. A concerned christian mom has rewritten the harry potter books to remove references to witchcraft. The harry potter books combine the intricate plotting of a mystery with the sweep and scope of epic fantasy and the intimacy and character development of a classic. The worst the future might say of harry potter is that it is a classic in the sense that p g wodehouse is a classic, rather than in the sense that henry james is.
Harry potter and the rise of the ordinary person novel. There are at least two big things to take away from this title. So, take another bite of turkish delight and fall in love with this classic in all of its renditions. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix is the longest book in the series, at 766 pages in the uk version and 870 pages in the us version. As a result, the most powerful themes of the harry potter books are about identityand they are profoundly countercultural. Jul 16, 2011 one recurring question concerns whether the harry potter books are quality literature, popular fad or a bit of both. Harry potter has an obscure origin, he is supplied with companions throughout his journey, and the young wizard seeks an object, which turns out to be no more than a symbol of what he actually finds. He was amongst the greatest wizards to have ever lived, often considered to be the second most powerful wizard in. Harry potter star alan rickman expressed frustrations over. Rowlings harry potter books are wonderful fantasy novels with powerful messages for kids and the ability to make even reluctant readers eager readers.
Again, his wand comes in handy, and with saying the spell name, poof. The first edition of harry potter and the philosophers stone is the only book in the series that credits joanne rowling as its author j. Did harry potter really steal all these story ideas. The hero story has been portrayed for centuries with early works present in the works of homer and hesiod. Others mistake you for unhappy on a regular basis, but simply do not understand that you are different and that is completely okay. Harry potter and the gothic novel by elizabeth murray. It wont be considered between the likes of jrr tolkien and cs lewis for language, but for story, perhaps. Harry potter is not the best written novel, but it will no doubt go down in history as a classic. Is the harry potter series good enough to go along with other prestigious classic novels such as moby dick, to kill a mockingbird, and the catcher in the rye. More than anything else, rowlings idea of what really matters is. Harrys mother protecting harry from voldemort is the sacrifice made from love that leads to harrys fate in the future. If you own one of these rare books, youre sitting on a.
317 709 302 783 1610 847 1389 899 454 1082 1280 1091 821 1019 1261 616 911 44 309 78 1496 1307 984 1487 147 186 101 1173 852 1273 468 1341 984 1131 34 182 518